Abstract
This papers
reports results of a cross sectional self-administered questionnaire study on ethical knowledge among medical students at
the Institute
of Medicine of Universiti Brunei Darussalam. The primary objective of
the research was to establish the general level of knowledge and understanding medical students to provide a baseline that
can be used to assess student progress as they move through the medical course. The results of data analysis would be used
in refining the design of the ethico-legal section of the undergraduate medical curriculum. The questionnaire had previously
been used in a similar study [1]. The questionnaire had a total of 40 scenarios distributed as follows: knowledge of ethics
8 (4 general and 4 Islamic), attitude & practice 21 (15 general and 6 Islamic), and opinions 11 (Islamic). After explaining
the aims and procedures of the study as well as obtaining written consent, students were asked to complete and return the
questionnaire. Students had to choose the best of 3-4 alternative solutions for the ethical dilemma in each scenario. Each
alternative had, unknown to the student, an embedded interpretation based on general and Islamic ethical principles. The interpretation
was the one coded for statistical analysis. Knowledge scenarios were coded as ‘do know’, ‘do not know’,
‘not sure’, or ‘avoid. Attitude and practice alternatives were coded as ‘avoid’, ‘take
action’, ‘refer’, or ‘report’. Opinion alternatives were coded as ‘acceptable’,
‘not acceptable’ or ‘not sure’. SPSS and STATA statistical packages were used for data management
and data analysis. Proportions were computed with 95% confidence intervals. Cross tabulations were made and associations were
tested using Fisher’s exact test because of the small numbers. Twenty nine out of a study population of 30 students
returned questionnaires. The gender distribution was 14 males and 15 females. There was no significant variation of gender
by year of study. The results for general scenarios were as follows: (a) knowledge: ‘do
know’ 54.9%, ‘do not know’ 44%, and ‘not sure’ 11%; (b) attitude and practice: ‘avoid’
10.3%, ‘take action’ 64.8%, ‘refer’ 7.9%, or ‘report’ 17.0%. The results for Islamic scenarios
were as follows: (i) knowledge: ‘do know’ 54.4%, ‘do not know’ 21%, ‘not sure’ 14.5%,
‘avoid’ 2.4% or ‘refer’ 7.7%; (ii) attitude and practice: ‘avoid’
1.6%, ‘take action’ 85.9%, ‘refer’ 10.8%, or ‘report’ 1.6%; and (iii) opinions: ‘acceptable’
80.1%, ‘not acceptable’ 17.2% or ‘not sure’ 2.6%. Year of study, gender, and ethnicity had no significant
statistical effect on ethics KAP. Several conclusions can be drawn from the preliminary analysis pending confirmation in larger
studies. The conclusion from the analysis is the proportion of students with expected knowledge of ethics was about 55%. Students
are more likely to confront ethical dilemmas to find a solution than they are likely to avoid them, report them, or refer
them to someone else. The proportions preferring taking action were 64.8% for general scenarios and 85.9% for Islamic scenarios.
Ethical opinions were in high agreement with Islamic ethical principles.
1. Naznin Muhammad et al. The impact of the teaching of medical ethics in the medical
and allied health sciences curriculum in International Islamic University Malaysia.
Paper being submitted to the International Medical Journal (personal communication)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Key words: ethics knowledge medical students
|